Garnett Theatre

Here is a picture (from the L.A. Public Library collection) of the Garnett Theatre, taken about 1909, when it was still called Tally's New Broadway.

The USC archive has the same photo as Joe posted above, but with more detail:
http://tinyurl.com/pbrhv

The Elden Hotel, to the left of the theatre, is still there.

I believe it was built in 1893. It currently has stores on the ground floor and the top two floors are not occupied. It was recently (2006) repainted and looks a little better.

The building was demolished in the late 1920s to make way for an expansion of the May Company department store. Source.

LM: The Silent Era source is mistaken. They have conflated the actual Tally's New Broadway (this theatre, later called the Garnett) at 554 S. Broadway with Tally's Broadway Theatre at 833 S. Broadway. That was the one demolished in 1929 to make way for the expansion of the May Company southward from its original 8th and Broadway building.

The Garnett has also been demolished, of course, but I'm not sure in what year. It was replaced by the Silverwood's store, which was there by 1913 (at least if the L.A. Library is right about the date of this photo from their collection.) I believe ScottS is probably correct about the 1893 construction date of the Elden Hotel. The building complex along Mercantile Place which adjoined the hotel property on the north (and was eventually replaced by the Arcade Building) dated from about that same time.

So had anyone found an opening date for this theatre? It must be sometime between 1902, when Tally opened his Electric Theatre on Spring St, and 1909, when he traded this site in for the site at 833 (the Broadway Theatre).

I'm wondering if this was the first movie theatre on Broadway?

We haven't pinned down the opening year for the Garnett/Tally's New Broadway yet. From this photograph at the USC Archives we can see that the theatre pre-dated the Story Building on the SE corner of 6th and Broadway, on which construction began in 1908.

This theatre definitely predates the oldest surviving theatre on Broadway, the Cameo, which opened in 1910 as Clune's Broadway. As far as Tally's being the first movie theatre built on Broadway, it's quite possible, though it's also possible that a storefront nickelodeon or two opened earlier.

The large version of the ca.1909 photo of the theatre linked by kenmc on Oct. 6 2006 has moved. It's here now. Noting the decoration along the top of the structure, it appears that Tally's and Silverwood's shared the same building. Silverwood's at first occupied only a corner spot, and eventually expanded to occupy the entire building (ca.1913). By the 1920s they were in the multi-story building which remains on that site today.

Tally's second Broadway at 833 also predates Clune's: it opened in May 1910, versus October for the Clune's...

The 1909 photo moved again, and is now here:
http://digarc.usc.edu/assetserver/controller/item/chs-m1519/CHS-31124

and the side view, just past Silverwood's, is now here:
http://digarc.usc.edu/assetserver/controller/item/chs-m122/CHS-6365

Were there two identical roof signs between this and the Tally's Broadway, or was it moved from one location to the other?