Ziegfeld Theatre

141 W. 54th Street,
New York, NY 10019

Unfavorite 131 people favorited this theater

Showing 2,326 - 2,350 of 4,511 comments

exit
exit on September 27, 2007 at 9:27 pm

How might one contact Mr. Endres by email?

exit
exit on September 27, 2007 at 9:24 pm

Mr E: is the current title curtain at the Zieg too sheer to be used effectively, or can the curtain warmer lights prevent seeing the screen through it?

I knew that projecting things onto the curtain had been done before, thanks for the examples, I tried to do it for a screening at the DGA but the slide projector wasn’t bright enough. And yes, one adventage of digital projection is the ability to easily throw an image onto the curtain or to fill a ghastly naked screen for the walk-in.

The Bridge effectively uses a simple slide of their logo against a black background. (Black background means you never see the edges of the slide) ArcLight throws up this awful dirty blurry slide of nobodyknows what (their signature image is a pair of blurry hands trying to form a A – not artsy, just stupid) and the slides never fill the screen, so they look like exactly that, a dirty blurry slide of nothing recognizable. Instead of making the place look classy, it has the opposite effect, looks amateurish, or like a classroom with an overhead projector aimed at the wall.

Mr Endres: How would you present a roadshow at the Ziegfeld today?

And where may we read this times article on projection that includes talk of your use of the curtains?

RobertEndres
RobertEndres on September 27, 2007 at 8:29 pm

I worked at the Ziegfeld when both curtains were in daily use, as well as having a main curtain, and until the “Snow White” stage presentation at Radio City, a title curtain there as well. I also have both a main and a title curtain in the screening room I’m in now. A few years ago the New York Times did an article on projection and interviewed me while I was running the 70mm print of “Pink Floyd: The Wall” at the Ziegfeld, and described the curtian use in some detail.

At the Zieg we would take the house lights and curtain warmers down to a pre-show level and open the main curtain followed by the title curtain as the trailers/shorts hit the screen. At the end of the pre-show material, I’d close the title curtain in and take the lights down to show level, hit the title curtain with the logo of the feature and then open the title curtain. Since the contour curtain at Radio City takes a good 20 sec. to get in and out, after it was going up, we’d start the shorts, etc and the the title curtain (or golds in that case) would open. We would also close it in before starting the feature. The golds control at Radio City gave a choice of four speeds to match the logo length, so the title curtain would be fully open as the company logo ended. I like to see the company logo hit the title curtain and have it opening as the logo fades. Martin Hart has an interesting section on this on the AWSM site. If we were running an overture at Radio City it is absolutely necessary to get the contour out of the way before it starts as the contour effectively muffles the high frequency horns as it comes in. It was interesting to listen to the sound at the end of the credits on a feature as it came in and hear the effect.

By the way, your idea of projecting a slide with a logo was used at the Michael Todd Theatre in Chicago for “Becket” when they projected a sword on the closed curtains before the start of the 70mm roadshow edition. The Chicago Theatre did something similar with their Hall & Connelly FR10 Spot/Effect Projectors. At one point in the late 60’s or early 70’s they had a couple of really interested stagehands who kept adding lights and effects for the intermissions. The FR10’s are pattern projectors (we had two in the booth at Radio City), and for a Frank Sinatra movie they projected a silhouhtte of Sinatra’s profile over the end credit crawl, and then as the curtains closed left it on the curtain. They did the same thing with a Japanese umbrella for a James Bond movie set in Japan. I had a Plitt Theatre pass and would stop by the Chicago every time I was in the Loop just to see what they had added. Now of course, with video projection it would be easier to scan in feature art work as a Powerpoint and project it. That would add a little showmanship even if the house didn’t have a curtain. The problem of course,is that it would conflict with the pre-show ads.

exit
exit on September 27, 2007 at 7:45 pm

Wow, Mr. Endres! …You know, I learned your name years ago in one of my early encounters with RCMH, (I think you were in the souvenir program) so you were a big name in my mind all these years. Reading your posts today is like being able to go back and interact with that great era of Showmanship. Someone should do a book of your stories, you’re like living history! (actually I know someone who would love to interview you) It’s a priviledge to hear from you. Please take good care of yourself, you are an invaluable resource.

(Hoping that comes off as sincere respectful appreciation rather than sycophantic ass-kissing)

Back to topic: does anyone have anything specific to say about the Ziegfeld’s second curtain, what it was put there for, and how it should be used today (particularly for a roadshow)? BTW, interesting what you get from a google search on the words “roadshow” or “cinema showmanship.” Wikipedia has a long definition of roadshow that’s generally accurate.

I really think that kind of showmanship can be appreciated by today’s audiences. In a conversation some time ago with an ArcLight manager about how their upper management has no clue of showmanship, I mentioned that projecting a slide of the feature’s logo onto the curtain as the audience arrived would be a nice touch. Many months later I heard people who had never experienced any kind of cinema showmanship talk enthusiastically about the Roadshow run of DREAMGIRLS at the Cinerama Dome… Several of them said “…and they had the name of the movie on the curtain when we walked in, it was SO Cool!”

So two questions for the rest of you: what is the intended purpose and best (most theatrical) use of the Ziegfeld’s second curtain, and don’t you think that if exhibitors got a clue about showmanship (and some advice on how to do it well) it would make a difference to today’s moviegoers?

RobertEndres
RobertEndres on September 27, 2007 at 6:05 pm

Bob: I’ve known (and admired) Bob Eberenz for years. He would have worked with Warren Jenkins on a number of projects including Cine Mix a film re-recording studio located in one of the Radio City screening rooms which utilized the some of the first 35mm Magna-Tech recorders and dubbers and on the Mercury “Living Presence” recordings. He probably has some stories about working with Warren and Bill Nafash on Otto’s room.

By the way, another Otto story that Warren told was also a gem. Otto had a JAN 16mm projector in his booth that could be rolled into position and which was equipped with special torque motor driven reel arms that could hold an entire 16mm feature on one big reel (he had a 16mm print of “Porgy” stored in the booth). One night Warren got home from a show change at the Hall and was told by his wife that Otto had called and was having problems. Warren hopped in a cab and went uptown. When he walked into the booth, Otto was standing there in his jumpsuit, ankle deep in 16mm film shaking his hand at Warren. Warren walked over and flipped the torque motor switch to “on”, and the take-up reel started turning. Otto had threaded the projector and started it remotely from his coffe table controls without the take-up reel turning, thus dumping a whole feature on the floor. It took the two of them a fair amount of time to get the film off the floor and back onto the reel, at which point Otto invited Warren into the room itself and opened a bottle of Courvosier, which they proceeded to finish off while Otto entertained Warren with stories about his career. Warren said it was a memorable evening, but it took him the rest of the next day to recover.

Please say, “Hi!” to Bob Eberenz for me tonight.

Bill Huelbig
Bill Huelbig on September 27, 2007 at 5:20 pm

There were some scenes of the men gambling in the street, and Sammy Davis Jr. sold “happy dust” which most likely was cocaine, but people of all races do stuff like that in big cities even today. The lyrics are written in dialect (“I Loves You, Porgy”) but the songs are so beautifully composed and performed that I soon forgot to notice it.

frankie
frankie on September 27, 2007 at 5:15 pm

All in all, an exciting experience. Not a perfect print, but pretty good. very moving to see the film again. The audience was with it all the way. Going out, I yelled at that peppy usher in the lobby: “Next year, "Gypsy” !!!"

Mike (saps)
Mike (saps) on September 27, 2007 at 5:11 pm

Any racial aspects of Porgy and Bess that might seem insensitive to our modern sensibilities? (Although a recent commentator’s amazement that black patrons weren’t cursing up a storm at Sylvia’s Restaurant makes me think that there’s still a ways to go.)

BobFurmanek
BobFurmanek on September 27, 2007 at 4:55 pm

Robert: The gentleman that I am referring to is Mr. Bob Eberenz. He has worked in the film industry since the mid-1940’s, and his resume in the business is quite extensive. He will be at the Ziegfeld tonight.

Bill Huelbig
Bill Huelbig on September 27, 2007 at 4:46 pm

I think we all grew up hearing horror stories about Otto Preminger, but now I’m starting to wonder how justified that reputation really is. If he was such a terror to work with, why did so many actors and film artists work with him multiple times? Hope Preminger talked last night about cinematographer Leon Shamroy and how he and Otto tried to work together whenever they could. Carol Lynley told me personally that she really enjoyed working with him. Even Tom Tryon, whom Otto supposedly badgered to a level close to torture on the set of “The Cardinal”, came back to make “In Harm’s Way” with him two years later. And after the story Robert Endres told … well, Otto certainly was a fascinating person.

Bill Huelbig
Bill Huelbig on September 27, 2007 at 4:31 pm

Jeff: From now on, whenever I see your panic button, I’ll be reminded of the great Otto Preminger. Thanks for that wonderful story, Robert.

JeffS
JeffS on September 27, 2007 at 4:21 pm

Bob, Bill: See! Other’s designed their rooms with a panic button too! :)

RobertEndres
RobertEndres on September 27, 2007 at 4:13 pm

Bob Furmanek: I’d be interested to know who your person involved in Otto Preminger’s screening room is. When I came to Radio City Music Hall in ‘74 a number of our techs also worked for National Theatre Supply which supplied the projection equipment. Those included Warren Jenkins and Bill Nafash. I had heard a number of stories about the room, and then was called by the union to work there. I called the Preminger home to see if I could get in early before the screening to break in and familarize myself with the booth, and found myself talking to Otto himself. He said to come over anytime and I did. It was quite an evening as at one point while examining the print I heard, “How’s it going?” and turned to find Mr. P. himself standing there. We chatted a moment and then he left. A while later the butler showed up with a tray containing the same meal they were serving for their guests downstars. Just before the screening Hope Preminger came in as asked if I wanted coffee. I had just come to New York from Illinois and had grown up watching Preminger films (including “Porgy & Bess” in Todd-AO during it’s roadshow engagement at the McVickers Theatre in Chicago) so I was very much impressed by the Premingers. In fact, I never cashed the check I received as payment that first night because it was signed by Otto Preminger and was made out to “Robert Endres Projectionist”. I still have it as a bookmark in my edition of Richardson’s Bluebook of Projection.

I worked for them fairly frequently for a couple of years after that and was always blown away by their residence which was almost like an extension of the Museum of Modern Art with their Picasso hanging right outside the booth, Eames chairs (personally modified by the Eames for the den/screening room)and a Dubuffet sculpture just outside the powder room. It was also the only home screening room I’ve worked in which had a “balcony” on top of the projection booth outside the gym one level up where the Preminger twins could watch the movie away from the guests downstairs.

Ask your person who designed the room if he remembers the marble topped coffee table in the room which sat by the sofa in front of the booth ports (which were concealed by another huge painting which slid up the wall to reveal the ports when the booth was in use.) The marble top on the table rolled back to reveal projector and room controls — including a red button marked “Panic!”.

While I was cowed by Otto’s reputation as a rather fierce dictator, the Premingers and their children were always gracious and charming to me, and this whole discussion of “Porgy & Bess” has brought back a lot of fond memories.

JeffS
JeffS on September 27, 2007 at 4:09 pm

For the benefit of the technical and projectionist fellows out there, the magnetic preamp I use at home was made by Smart. It’s a 1 piece rack mounted, 1U high panel with self contained preamplifiers (basically 4 opamps) all one one circuit card. The SMP435 had no tone filter, the SMP430 before it, did.

Bill Huelbig
Bill Huelbig on September 27, 2007 at 4:06 pm

If any Star Trek fans are going tonight, look for Nichelle Nichols. She’s part of the large chorus and I believe I saw her in the background center screen during “It Ain’t Necessarily So”.

William
William on September 27, 2007 at 4:00 pm

It’s funny Dolby’s offices are just around the corner on 6th. Ave..

Bill Huelbig
Bill Huelbig on September 27, 2007 at 3:55 pm

For the benefit of tonight’s audience, I hope the Ziegfeld crew takes William’s advice and obtains a copy of that Dolby card!

At the end of the show, someone called out that it was also George Gershwin’s birthday. September 26th sure was an important day in the history of the American musical.

Vito
Vito on September 27, 2007 at 3:52 pm

Ah yes William, there ya go. I knew there had to be a reason we no longer had the problem after the 70s, thanks for clearing that up.
Perhaps since the Zeigfeld booth has now been “downgraded”,
Clearview will go the extra mile and install the card.
I imagine Dolby is giving them away cheap at this point.

William
William on September 27, 2007 at 3:52 pm

The tone system for surrounds was used with Ampex theatre sound systems. Many older theatres that were equipped for 70MM and 35mm mag sound had Ampex sound systems till the earlier to middle 1970’s.

Vito
Vito on September 27, 2007 at 3:40 pm

Jeff, I just cannot recall when the tone issue was no longer a problem. I would have to go back to the late 60s, just about the time 4 track prints were beginning to become scarce.

Bill, “Tonight,tonight, won’t be just any night”, at the Zeigfeld.

William
William on September 27, 2007 at 3:37 pm

The problem is they did not have a Dolby cat.93 card in the MPU unit in the booth. This card was make by Dolby for use in the MPU-1 for running older 4-Track mag films. With that card in place the it will filter out that tone and trigger the surrounds.

JeffS
JeffS on September 27, 2007 at 2:38 pm

Ditto: Downgraded? What a joke.

Vito: My preamp at home doesn’t have the filter. It was designed and built after the era when the tone system was used. The model built prior to mine did have the filter, with jumpers to enable or disable it. Consequently, when I run certain mag films, I have to keep the surround speaker off.

Bill Huelbig
Bill Huelbig on September 27, 2007 at 2:34 pm

I think he meant the word “downgraded” facetiously. Some people laughed when he said it.

Bill Huelbig
Bill Huelbig on September 27, 2007 at 2:33 pm

Vito, you mentioned “West Side Story”. You may be interested to know that it all started 50 years ago last night, when it opened on Broadway at the Winter Garden Theatre, 9/26/57. I passed the Winter Garden on my walk to the Port Authority after leaving the Ziegfeld, with “West Side Story” playing on my iPod all the way.

Vito
Vito on September 27, 2007 at 2:31 pm

Seriously, “downgraded”? How rude!