Guthrie Theatre

azileangel on April 19, 2006 at 7:15 am

I’ve lived in Sandy Lake since I was eight. This has been one of the only theaters I go to. The popcorn is good and doesn’t make you sick; they have bottles of pop instead of foundatin, and the price is right. The balcony finally reopened a couple of years ago but just for the adults. Even with the new multi theater plexes, I still love going to the Guthrie!

csambuchino on August 31, 2007 at 12:37 pm

Great theater

Joe Vogel on November 5, 2009 at 11:02 pm

An item in the July 31, 1937, issue of Boxoffice said that J.G. Carruthers and H.M. Carruthers had bought the Guthrie Theatre from Mrs. Martha Guthrie, widow of the original owner, and would take over operation of the house on August 2. John Guthrie had opened the house ten years earlier, on August 1, 1927. The Guthrie Theatre had 870 seats at the time of the sale.

An August 7 Boxoffice item about the sale said that J.G. Carruthers had begun his theater career in John Guthrie’s Lyric Theatre at Grove City, the town’s first movie house, which Guthrie had opened in 1907. Carruthers mentioned the Guthrie Theatre’s mascot, a stuffed eagle then mounted over the foyer fireplace, which had originally been placed over the boxoffice of the Lyric and had thereafter been displayed in each of Guthrie’s theaters.

Mrs. Guthrie, who had taken over the theater after her husband’s death in December, 1934, was interviewed for Boxoffice Magazine’s issue of June 1, 1935. The article included three small photos of the theater, and said that Mrs. Guthrie (to whom it referred rather quaintly- or perhaps disturbingly- as “an exhibitress”) had recently redecorated the theater. She described it thus:

“The stage set represents a Spanish exterior, side walls treated with over drapes and backings decorated with placques copied from the ‘Guthrie’ and ‘Montgomery’ coats of arms (Martha Montgomery having been my former name.) The curtain is appliqued with a Spanish character design. The organ grilles have balconies decorated with Spanish shawls, carrying out the same scheme as the balcony of the theatre. The foyer arch and standee rail are also draped, and double doors with glass panels were also added to the foyer, as well as a fireplace which was built in. The ceiling is covered in a canopy effect. A baby grand piano refinished in antique ivory is placed on the stage. The organ has been entirely overhauled by Mr. Herman Stahl of Erie, Pa., who built it.”

The accompanying photo of the auditorium shows the expanse of fabric it sported, including the great billows suspended from the ceiling. It makes me wonder what her fire insurance must have cost, and how the place ever escaped becoming an inferno during her tenure there.

Martha Guthrie made use of her Mad Decorating Skilz later on, as the August 28, 1943, issue of Boxoffice said that she was then running an interior decoration business in Grove City. She continued to be mentioned in the magazine occasionally as late as 1948, then vanished until 1969 when the issue of July 28 carried a brief notice of her recent death. By then she had become a “former exhibitor,” rather than a former “exhibitress.”

thom5340 on May 9, 2019 at 10:22 am

I just returned from my visit to the Guthrie. The restoration is wonderful and the theatre is operational. Seating has already been increased and final count will be +500 seats, The Balcony now has 50 Recliner seats and new seating on the Main floor is coming.

Discussion has begun to install an Organ in the theatre. It originally had a Herman Stahl pipe organ. The 2 Organ Chambers are spacious.

I will keep you informed as things develop – but this is going to be great!

Anyone wishing to contact me directly may do so:

richardg on October 17, 2022 at 7:28 pm

It was a Sunday afternoon almost two weeks before the official re-opening of the Guthrie. I’d had only expected to see the theatre from the outside. The wide-open theatre door, however, was too inviting for me to resist. Pat, the new owner of one year, was busy doing paperwork in the foyer area. He lit up the six beautiful, ceiling, crystal chandeliers so I could see the immaculate auditorium. The fifty or so rockers in balcony were removed and replaced with tables and chairs. Seating capacity is approximately 400 but the distance between the stage and the first row of seating would permit the addition of several movable chairs to be added. A barbershop occupies one of the two theatre’s store fronts. The other contains commercial grade restaurant equipment which will be used for the theatre’s new menu. A new and beautiful oak bar dominates the lobby area and hopefully will provide enough extra revenue to keep this lovely single screen gem open for many years. Pat seems willing try all venues to create a successful operation. It will start with movies and a variety of live acts. Pat has operated several successful restaurants in the past so there’s no reason to believe this won’t follow the same course.