New York, NY - NYC’s Most Incredible Old Movie Theaters

posted by ThrHistoricalSociety on August 4, 2016 at 7:04 am


From Paper Magazine: Before cineplexes—and before you could easily access old movies at home—going to see a movie was a completely special adventure. You had to leave the house, often entering some eccentrically glorious theater that added, in its grandiosity (or sometimes squalor), to the cinematic quality of the experience. Here are some of those lost treasures du NYC cinema:

THE RIVOLI (1620 Broadway)

A big, gorgeous theater between 49th and 50th Streets, the Rivoli played host to Oscar fare like West Side Story, Cleopatra, and The Sound of Music, which all attracted big crowds of people plopping their money down for some larger-than-life showboating. The huge screen gave a panoramic view into beautifully art directed films, making them seem even more spectacular than they were. Opened in 1917, the Rivoli eventually became the UA Twin, and then in 1987, it closed, paving the way for yet another skyscraper. Also: The Guild, 33 W. 50th Street, a beautiful, gilded Rockefeller Center area theater where I saw a re-release of Fantasia. It’s now a Nautica.

THE WAVERLY THEATER (325-Avenue of the Americas)

In the 1960s, the Waverly was immortalized in the musical Hair as the place where a hippie girl said she met “a guy called Frank Mills” and was desperate to have him back. In the 1970s, it went on to be a home for interactive Rocky Horror Picture Show showings that drew throngs of just-coming-out kids and their allies, fully dressed for a time warp. In the 1980s, the campy, socially conscious Hairspray was a big hit there. Today, it’s the IFC Center, a safe space for docs.

THALIA (2537 Broadway)

This weirdly shaped theater with an art deco interior was a bit of a dive, but it showed wonderful old films, and was featured IN a wonderful film, when it got a shout out in Annie Hall. It closed in 1987, briefly reopening in 1993 and again in 1996 before being subsumed into Symphony Space. Also: The Regency Theater, a West Side revival house full of foreign gems.


The most charming of all the revival houses, this one showed vintage double bills (All About Eve and Sunset Boulevard) in a cozy East Village setting that reeked of old Hollywood coming to NYC. Big stars like Gloria Swanson, Joan Crawford, and Ruby Keeler had been there and put their foot or hand prints in the cement outside, starting your experience with some glamorous realness. Inside, the crowd was fanatically devout; my friend and I got yelled at once for talking in the middle of Harriet Craig—and they were right. The space went on to showcase live theater.

THE ZIEGFELD (141 W. 54th Street)

It was a tragedy when this long running theater—the largest single screen movie place in NYC—shuttered due to dwindling receipts earlier this year. Through the decades, the Ziggy featured an array of A-list films, as well as premieres and galas that made moviegoing unique and elaborate. It’ll be turned into the Ziegfeld Ballroom event space, where we can dance around and try to relive the memories. (Also sorely missed are art houses Carnegie Hall Cinema, 881-7th Avenue, and the nearby Little Carnegie, 146 W. 57th Street. And I loved seeing movies at Radio City Musical Hall, accompanied by a stage show, complete with high-kicking Rockettes. In my youth, I saw Broadway adaptations like The Odd Couple and Mame there, making for truly gala evenings).

THE WALKER THEATER (6401-18th Avenue, Brooklyn)

Opened in 1926, this grand palace lasted all the way until 1988, but for me, its bizarre heyday was the rockin' 1960s. That’s when the Walker became my salvation because I happened to grow up in the neighborhood and found a catharsis in the wacky succession of films they showed there. At that time, the Walker only seemed to showcase flop movies that had bombed in other theaters, so I got to enjoy Boom! (a wacky melodrama with Liz Taylor and Richard Burton), The April Fools (a romantic comedy starring Jack Lemmon and Catherine Deneuve), and other duds, not thinking they were bad at all.

THE ELGIN (19th Street and 8th Avenue)

A pioneer of the art of midnight movies, the Elgin showed such culty classics as El Topo, Eraserhead, and The Harder They Come, all attracting a slightly high crowd looking for something offbeat. Even when it was an adult theater, they featured midnight movies of cult films! The place closed in 1978 and these days, it’s the classy Joyce Theater, where dance is served.

THE PARADISE (2403 Grand Concourse, the Bronx)

Also known as Loew’s Paradise, this resplendent theater was designed to evoke a 16th Century Italian baroque garden, thank you. Opened in 1929, it lasted all the way until 1994, and was landmarked three years later. Eventually, the space was leased to a church, which must have the most dazzling services in the country.

LOEW’S VALENCIA (165-11 Jamaica Avenue, Queens)

An incredibly ornate, golden movie palace constructed in 1929, this one originally served movies, vaudeville acts, and live organ playing, like so many of the other such establishments. In 1977, the strucure was donated to the Tabernacle of Prayer for all People. It’s a real beaut! Similarly, the Kings Theatre (1027 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn) is an exquisite, refurbished ex movie house. Last year, I saw a perfectly enjoyable production of Annie there.

THE RIALTO (1481 Broadway)

In the 1970s, this was an extremely real Times Square porn palace (along with many others that are long gone) and seemed as doomed as the Howard Johnson’s clam special. A typical movie shown might have been “The ABCs of Marriage” (advertised as “better than a marriage manual,” not to mention “frank, educating, explicit”). In 1980—even before the big time cleaning up of Times Square—the Rialto became a legit theater with TV studios, and in 2002, it became just another office building. Obscene!

Story link, with photos of each theater:

ABOUT THEATRE HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA: Founded by Ben Hall in 1969, the Theatre Historical Society of America (THS) celebrates, documents and promotes the architectural, cultural and social relevance of America’s historic theatres. Through its preservation of the collections in the American Theatre Architecture Archive, its signature publication Marquee™ and Conclave Theatre Tour, THS increases awareness, appreciation and scholarly study of America’s theatres.

Learn more about historic theatres in the THS American Theatre Architecture Archives and on our website at


Comments (4)

SethLewis on August 4, 2016 at 1:38 pm

Great piece…would like to see more on The Plaza 58th between Madison & Park (Now Tao Restaurant) and some of the Spanish theatres the Eagle and Cosmo

JackIndiana on August 4, 2016 at 3:21 pm

I remember seeing a double feature of MEATBALLS and FOUL PLAY at the Walker one summer night in 1979. The house was packed and the laughter shook the walls. One of my fondest movie memories.

cmbussmann on August 8, 2016 at 7:33 am

Kinda depressing when you consider how many of these gems have either been shuttered, demolished, or repurposed.

MissAmanda on August 15, 2016 at 11:10 am

The Elgin also showcased Reefer Madness and Pink Flamingos. I also remember seeing a Buster Keaton festival there — just about every silent film that Keaton ever made. Also a Marx Brothers festival. And who can forget the ominous warning short that would come on, accompanied by doomsday-sounding music, before the feature: “If you must smoke … smoking is permitted ONLY in the balcony!”

You must login before making a comment.

New Comment