Lyric Theatre

16-18 Seigel Street,
Brooklyn, NY 11206

Unfavorite No one has favorited this theater yet

Showing 8 comments

Astyanax
Astyanax on June 11, 2011 at 3:36 pm

The marker should actually be closer to B'way.

johndereszewski
johndereszewski on June 7, 2011 at 7:06 pm

Ed, you caught the current location of this old theater just about right. Thanks.

Ed Solero
Ed Solero on May 30, 2011 at 4:43 pm

Hey Astyanax… I just updated the street view to face the Lindsay Park housing looking across Manhattan Avenue from Seigel Street. Since the stretch of Seigel Street where the theater was located is no longer in existence, I believe this is the best mapping we can obtain, without entering a completely false address to move the marker closer to Leonard Street or Broadway.

Astyanax
Astyanax on May 30, 2011 at 10:16 am

I question the map location of the theatre based on the street address. Before the construction of the Lindsay Park Housing complex, Siegel Street began at Broadway, 2 blocks to the south. These blocks contained residential and light manufacturing units. The address listed for the Lyric would have placed it between B'way & Leonard St. and not at the corner of Manhattan Av.

johndereszewski
johndereszewski on April 17, 2011 at 7:34 am

I was the person who just added the Italian Theatre, but I only did so after being reasonably sure that it possessed – unlike the Gayety – some cinematic history. A cinematic link need not be strong – in the case of the Lyric, it may only have occurred during its first two years of existence – but their must be something. Otherwise, many theaters that never presented a single movie could find their way to the cinema movie list. I think the site moderators are quite justified in insisting on this policy.

This issue has received some attention on other pages – see, e.g., Cinema Warsaw – and, unlike other commentators, I have taken a pretty generous position for inclusion – as long as SOME sort of cinematic history could be documented or strongly inferred.

Ret. AKC (NAC) CCC Bob Jensen, Manteno, Illinois
Ret. AKC (NAC) CCC Bob Jensen, Manteno, Illinois on April 17, 2011 at 6:03 am

John, the theater happened to be added to Cinema Treasures, how can we know for sure that movies never were shown in that theater? I say let it stay on CT. It would be a shame to remove it if it had shown films and if it didn’t, I guess it’s not the end of the world, it’s just a Theater Treasure.

johndereszewski
johndereszewski on April 17, 2011 at 3:55 am

Well, no sooner had I noted the lack of a cinematic link to the Italian Theatre than no one other than the Brooklyn Theatre Index’s author politely pointed out one to me. Thanks Cezar, and I will be adding this site soon.

johndereszewski
johndereszewski on April 16, 2011 at 1:24 pm

Before submitting this page, I was especially careful to note that the Lyric had actually served as a movie palace for some time – in this case for at least two years. This is an important consideration since the Brooklyn Theatre Index does not draw a distinction between theaters that had motion picture histories from those that did not.

This consideration places the Lyric in contrast to two Williamsburg based theaters noted in the Index that did not apparently possess a cinematic history. The first – the Gayety, situated at 18-22 Throop Avenue – had a long and distinguished history as a legitimate theater venue. However, nothing cinematic has been documented here.

In addition, the Italian Theatre, once situated at 260 Bushwick Avenue between 1911-17, may -or may not – have been a movie palace. It could just have easily have been an ethnic theater – such as the current day hispanic Thalia Theater in Sunnyside Queens – that presented drama in Italian and possibly some opera, but nothing cinematic.

Until come evidence appears that movies were actually played at these theaters, the Gayety and the Italian should not have pages in Cinema Treasues. But if anything cinematic turns up, they should certainly join the crowd.

I hope anyone who knows anything about the Lyric, Gayety and Italian theaters can enlighten about their interesting histories now.